I make a point to power down my cellphone as I step into a movie theater. Not just on silent mode – totally powered down. I mention this not from a place of judgment, or to imply that the ghost of Billy Wilder will return to offer approval. I see it as a simple little pleasures: for no less than an hour and a half, I am totally incommunicado. I leave my phone off for the duration of the scroll as well. It strikes me as decadent to remain seated as other patrons gradually exit, illuminated solely by the scrolling names.
And, increasingly, by the illumination of the Letterboxd app.
Over twenty-six million individuals use Letterboxd, a movie-logging app. Like A24, it has become a marker for a particular kind of aficionado who hypes new releases and revels in unearthing cinematic treasures. Members score and write about films, and the wittiest or most profound commentaries become popular, motivating film lovers to put in effort.
"If I don't jot down my ideas quickly after the credits roll, my write-ups are significantly less lucid and well-put," noted one user.
On a recent visit to the theater, the credits had barely started before the patron in the row ahead started composing his review. Not far away, a duo lingered, heads bowed, jotting down their respective thoughts.
The legendary artist David Lynch shared some wisdom: note every brilliant thought the very second it occurs to you. Otherwise, it could vanish, and, in his words: "If you forget a good idea, it makes you want to commit suicide." Although Lynch advised hopeful creators, a similar ethos pertains to the Letterboxd experience.
One young man, a 20-year-old university attendee in New York, always drafts his reviews before leaving the auditorium.
"Unless I jot down my ideas promptly when the film concludes, my critiques are significantly less coherent and articulate," he explained. "The process demands a while. I take my time, and my partner doesn't like it."
Stern attends the movies frequently – on 182 occasions the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who sometimes must usher him out so they can start tidying the aisles. He thinks it perfectly fair to utilize the closing scroll: "When you pay for a movie ticket, the closing sequence are included in the movie."
Letterboxd's most ardent advocates credit the platform with reviving interest around a challenged film industry, where fewer films are made and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also has the sort of demographics companies seek – its primary segment of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Buzz creates additional buzz; highly awaited movies experience a flurry of reviews on Letterboxd immediately after the premiere showtimes. The top critique of an acclaimed movie – "Emily Brontë died long ago yet this version is still the most egregious event that has ever affected her" – has amassed more than 50,000 likes. A separate fictionalized retelling inspired this comparison to a major artist's documentary: "the Eras Tour documentary found dead."
"It's somewhat a compulsion," said Ben Glidden, a 33-year-old resident who works in marketing. He also prefers to jot down thoughts during the credits. "Thinking about what you just experienced, as soon as you watched it, aids the viewing experience. It clarifies the central themes of a film. If it evokes a sensation of comfort, that's not always something you recall five hours down the line."
This user feels most driven to critique a film if it was very good – or awful. Case in point: he recently sat through a sci-fi vehicle. "I found myself so disappointed by how profoundly awful it was, that I was excited to whip out my phone and award it a half-star rating," he said. (Glidden is a stricter critic than established professional critics, who awarded the film three stars, describing it as "clever and engaging fare.")
Another user, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who is in social media, viewed an Oscar-nominated feature at a cinema on the Upper West Side and stayed to draft the review ("it received the highest rating"). He has observed worse behavior: people whipping out their phones to review the movie they are in the middle of watching. "That annoys me," he said.
One of film's longest-running myths recounts a showing of a pioneering film that depicted a train arriving at a station. Cinema was in its infancy and – in line with this debunked anecdote – the footage of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera frightened the crowd so much that people ran away screaming.
A hundred and thirty years later, cinema etiquette is just as poor. It seems, few people understand how to behave in a theater any more, particularly when the theater darkens: audience members use their phones of the image, carry in smelly food, and, as seen during a cultural moment, sometimes get into physical altercations.
A number of users have taken to social media to discuss the propriety of "Letterboxding" in the credits. When one social media user